The sad case of Dr. Day
August 26th, 2003A MetaFilter article today innocently linked to the web site of a Scientology front organization that exists, essentially, to question the use of prescription drugs, particularly for mental illness.
Looking through the site, I found the page for their board of directors and there was Dr. Lorraine Day. Oh dear, I thought. What now?
I first encountered Dr. Day in 1988 or 89 when I was working for an orthopedic medical journal. She was one of our regular peer reviewers, and I found her a very impressive person. She’d clawed her way up from nothing through community college classes, a dental hygienist job, medical assistant, through nursing school and the nursing profession, to medical school, and finally had broken into one of the most notorious boy’s clubs in medicine: orthopedic surgery. She was at the time Chief of Surgery at San Francisco General Hospital and at the top of her profession.
Around the time I left that job, Dr. Day had stopped reviewing for us because she was “working full-time on the AIDS problem”, which sounded laudable to me. Unfortunately, it wasn’t. Like many healthcare workers, especially in places like San Francisco that got the full first wave of AIDS patients, she was very frightened of exposure to this deadly and poorly understood disease. As a surgeon who worked in one of the most splattery surgical specialties, she had more reason than most to worry about infection. And her early activism was an entirely appropriate criticism of the poor safety mechanisms in place to protect healthcare workers from exposure to HIV.
She then descended into ignorant gaybashing stupidity. She became the go-to person for the “Medical conservative viewpoint” on the talk shows, advocating restrictions of the basic civil rights of homosexuals, blaming gay men for AIDS, and in general feeding the Bigotry Monster. She appeared on TBN and the 700 Club constantly. She was shrill, and mean-spirited, and unscientific, and downright Un-American. I was sad because I’d thought of her before as kind of a career hero to me: someone who had triumphed over adversity to succeed and help others.
According to her web site, she acquired and then beat cancer recently. That’s cool. However, she’s also selling “natural cure” books, barley “dietary supplements” that cure everything, and a load of other prescientific and dangerous quackery all larded up with religious sentiment.
This is, quite literally, tragic. When I think of that long journey from nobody, through dental hygienist, up through the medical ranks to surgeon; of all of that skill, caring, and good hard scientific knowledge; and of all those years of experience that could be passed on; and I see a deranged fundamentalist herb-saleswoman leading on other sufferers to death? It makes me sad.
There’s a spot where paranoia, health-food crankery, know-nothing religion, and distrust of authority meet. That’s where Dr. Day has landed, 15 years after she abandoned her oath, started gaybashing and turned away from science.
Say it ain’t so, Dr. Day. Say you didn’t sell out to hatred and ignorance and fraud and Scientology and quackery. Say it ain’t so.